When To Use a Vignette and When Not To

 

#13 in the Judging a Photograph Series

.When to use a vignette and when not to. Photography tips on Falcondale Life blog. What is a vignette? Should it be black or white and how to decide whether to add it when editing a photo.

When you edit a photo the option will appear to add a vignette (pronounced “vin-yet”). It will darken the edges of the photo, like a thin black cloud. A true vignette is caused by zooming out and shooting a wide-angle photo. Remember, camera lenses are circular. You may think that all photos are rectangular but in fact they all begin as circles. When the edges of the circle are visible in the corners of your rectangular photo, that is a vignette.

Adding a Vignette

Artificial vignettes are a useful effect. When you are editing a photo, try it out. Generally, it is a matter of your own taste. A vignette can work to draw the eye to the centre of the image. You can use one when the edge of the image is relatively bright and fights for your attention. Perhaps the main subject in the centre is a bit darker than the surroundings. However you don’t want to use a vignette to darken the image too much.

White Vignette

There was a fashion in wedding photography in the 1980s and 1990s for a white vignette. It was quite an unnatural look, and really only worked like a blurry-edged frame. It’s definitely worth avoiding.

However if you are shooting pure white background product shots, you can try adding a white vignette improve the look of the white background. That’s the most practical use for the white vignette function. It works better on Aperture than on Lightroom for this. The average mobile app doesn’t offer this function, but if you have found a white vignette in an app, please do share it in the comments.

When to use a vignette and when not to. Photography tips on Falcondale Life blog. What is a vignette? Should it be black or white, and how to decide if it's a good idea to add it when editing a photo. Dodd Fell, Yorkshire Dales national park.

A Photo of Dodd Fell

I was very pleased with my photo of Dodd Fell mainly because of the sunlight. It had caught on the distant water in the cleft in the hills. Also I had managed to get most of the sheep to look at me! This was the first shot I took out of about twenty, and after this one, the sheep got bored and looked away. No amount of jumping up and down or clapping would get them to look back.

I added just the tiniest vignette and this was my mistake. Why? Because – as the competition judge explained to me – you should never put a vignette in the pale, flat sky. It is so obviously fake, it doesn’t improve the contrast in the sky and there is nothing there to benefit from being darkened. I still got second place though, so not bad!

Can you see that the judge was right? Or do you have a different view? Let me know in the comments.

If you are enjoying these blogs, I would be so grateful if you would please share them on Facebook or other social media. You can email them to friends too. Sharing buttons are at the end of the post. Thank-you!

Read the previous post in the Judging a Photograph series by clicking here.

Read the judging a Photograph series from the start by clicking here.

Photalife

13 Comments

  1. 17th April 2017 / 7:48 pm

    I’ve never added it in Lightroom. It has occasionally been in photo’s I’ve taken wide angle like you say but generally I tend to avoid them #mysundayphoto

  2. 16th April 2017 / 1:36 pm

    I LOVE the light in the background, such a great capture #MySundayPhoto

  3. 16th April 2017 / 12:54 pm

    Very interesting! I still have a lot to learn!
    #mysundayphoto

  4. 16th April 2017 / 10:51 am

    I don’t tend to use vignette but I think it looks good on your image. Congratulations on the place. #MySundayPhoto

  5. 16th April 2017 / 6:58 am

    Congrats on second place. It is a stunning photo, I love the light. I have no experience with vignettes so really enjoyed your post. #MySundayPhoto

  6. 16th April 2017 / 12:26 am

    Personally I live the little bit of vignette, it give a mood to the sky and drws you in to the valley.

  7. 16th April 2017 / 12:05 am

    We use vignette on Instagram to draw the attention to the centre of our images…it’s kinda our style and we like using it. But wouldn’t apply it with our pro camera or in Photoshop. #MySundayPhoto

  8. 16th April 2017 / 12:05 am

    Interesting to read about when it would be better not to use a vignette. I use them very rarely and only if it really does improve the photo – otherwise I tend not to. Not because of any technical know-how, just what looks best when I’m editing though!

  9. 15th April 2017 / 9:31 pm

    Useful information for an amateur like me! Nice work

  10. 15th April 2017 / 10:51 am

    Vignetting can make or break a photo

    Have a good Easter and thank you for linking up

    • 15th April 2017 / 11:03 am

      Quite right! It really can. Have a good weekend.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *